Rights and everyday life
Complaints and Disputes in France: How to Build Your Case
A complaint in France works when the problem is on record at once: photos and video in the first hour, then a letter or email, not a call. Next: registered post with proof of receipt and the free médiateur and conciliateur de justice. That's how we got compensation for a car rental cancelled an hour before it began.
Ask in the “Vibe South of France” chat how to word a complaint in your case
Living in France, we at Vibe South of France have learned one rule about disputes: whatever isn’t recorded at once might as well never have happened. In our experience, “that’s how it was, honestly” is hard to stand on without photos, letters and dates. So record it at once, put your complaint in writing and know where to get help for free. The law comes from official cards with their dates; the experience is our own. If something about your case is unclear, ask in our community chat on Telegram.
The first hour: photos, video and a message
The minutes after you move in, get the keys or pick up the car are worth more than any later argument. Until the place is yours, anything broken was broken by someone else.
A typical case: you book a flat for a trip through a booking platform, and when you arrive it has several serious problems. Unless you photograph them at once and report them on the platform itself, getting the money back later is hard: the platform may say it saw nothing, and the host that it’s not their doing. Hotels are no different: a broken washbasin you kept quiet about can easily become yours at check-out, and you have nothing to prove otherwise.
What to do:
- take photos and video: the whole flat or car first, then each fault close up;
- tell the host, the hotel or the rental company straight away, and report the problem in the booking app.
One more observation from the project’s owner, with no guarantees: people who firmly demand what they paid for, rather than simply asking, mostly get it.
Why a phone call doesn’t count
A call is hard to prove later: no text, no date, no record of what you were promised. Letters and emails stay. So after a conversation on the phone, send a short note: “As agreed today at 15:00, you will replace the car by tomorrow.”
For serious steps France has the registered letter with proof of receipt, the lettre recommandée avec accusé de réception (LRAR). You can also send it electronically: service-public (card F31463) says an electronic registered letter has the same legal force as a paper one and works in the same situations. Keep the proof of sending for at least a year.
The registered letter and the mise en demeure
A mise en demeure is a written demand that someone meet their obligation. It sets out what happened, with references to the contract and the dates, exactly what you are asking for (a repair, a replacement, a refund) and by when. Photos and copies of your correspondence go with it.
For tenants, service-public spells out the order: first tell the landlord about the problem; if nothing gets fixed, send a mise en demeure by registered letter with proof of receipt, using the official template R1746. If two months after the letter nothing has changed, you can turn to the commission départementale de conciliation (CDC) or a conciliateur de justice, and only then to the court. For a dispute of up to €5,000 this conciliation step is compulsory.
A leak in a rented flat: whose problem is it
This happened to us: after rain the roof leaked, and the landlady tried to pass both the repair and the insurance on to us. The law says otherwise.
| Question | What the law says |
|---|---|
| Who repairs the roof and a leak through it | The landlord: the home must have a roof that keeps water out (décret 2002-120), and the landlord does everything except réparations locatives (loi 89-462, art. 6) |
| What of this falls on the tenant | The roof is not on the réparations locatives list; the tenant only clears the gutters, and only if they alone use them (décret 87-712) |
| When the tenant pays | If the leak was the tenant’s fault; it is up to the tenant to prove it wasn’t (F21105) |
| What insurance the tenant must have | Only risques locatifs: fire, water, explosion, meaning liability towards the landlord (F31300) |
| When to tell the insurer | Within 5 working days; don’t start repairs without the insurer’s agreement (F1352) |
| Can you stop paying rent | No, the rent is due even while the landlord fails to repair (F31699) |
An important caveat: the tenant’s own belongings are covered only by multirisques habitation, and insurers usually exclude a leak through a worn-out roof. So “your insurance won’t cover this” can be true. All the more reason to stand firm that the roof is the landlord’s job. More on the lease and tenants’ rights is in the guide to renting a home in France.
Renting a car: a breakdown on the road and a cancelled booking
If two hours after you pick up the car it starts leaking oil or pulling to one side, that is not your fault. Film everything as soon as you can and send the rental company at least an email; better still, call and follow the call straight away with a written message.
What the rental company must do after a breakdown is set by its contract. What the law does require is that, before the rental, it tells you the deposit amount and how the deposit comes back, how fuel is charged, and what it commits to on repairs, assistance and a replacement car after a breakdown or accident (Institut national de la consommation). Save those terms on the day you book: they are what you will hold the company to. By law the rental price includes only insurance for your liability towards others; damage to the car itself is on you up to the excess (F23420).
Our story. We booked a car from a rental company, and an hour before the rental was due to start an email arrived: no cars. By then there were no free cars anywhere that day. We wrote to the company by email, and after a month of fairly calm correspondence it refunded the more expensive rental from another company and the accommodation we had to pay for because of its cancellation.
How to choose a rental company, which cards they accept and what to do about excess cover is in the guide to car rental in France.
If nobody answers: where to go for free
A written complaint to the company itself is the compulsory first step: without it, a consumer mediator won’t take on the dispute. After that, four doors open at no cost.
| Where | What it is | Conditions |
|---|---|---|
| Médiateur de la consommation | The mediator the company is attached to | Free for the consumer; no later than 1 year after your written complaint; proposes a solution within 90 days (justice.fr) |
| Conciliateur de justice | A conciliator who helps both sides agree without going to court | Free; any civil or commercial dispute, whatever the amount (F1736) |
| Point-justice | A place where staff explain your rights | Free and confidential; the single number 3039, opened in September 2021, finds you the nearest one |
| SignalConso | The DGCCRF’s government service for reporting companies | Free; it tells the company about the problem and the reply comes by email; it does not promise to settle your personal dispute |
The last step is court. What you need for it in your particular case, the same point-justice will explain for free.
A short checklist
- Photos and video in the first hour, wide shots and close-ups.
- A message the same day, in writing, asking them to confirm they received it.
- A call only together with an “as agreed” email.
- No answer: a mise en demeure by registered letter with proof of receipt, on paper or electronic.
- No result: the mediator, a conciliateur de justice, a point-justice.
Two more of our guides on the subject: opening a bank account in France and the titre de séjour. With the préfecture too, in our experience, emails and registered letters help keep a file moving.
If it is a theft or an assault, it is no longer a complaint to a company but a police report in France.
Ask our people
How to word a letter to a rental company or a landlord, and where the point-justice is in your town: ask in our Vibe South of France chat, t.me/vibe_sud_france, with 750+ members across the South and beyond. Longer conversations happen in our Facebook group, facebook.com/groups/vibesudfrance, so do join; photos from our meet-ups are on Instagram at instagram.com/vibesudfrance.
The “Vibe South of France” community chat on Telegram - moving, daily life and your rights in France
See Also
- Moving to the South of France: paperwork step by step
- Renting a home in France
- Opening a bank account in France
- Titre de séjour: residence permits in France
- First 30 days in France: what to do
- Buying a car in France: papers, carte grise, insurance
- Petrol prices in France, speed limits and toll roads
- Driving licence in France: who exchanges, who takes the exam
Sources
- Faire réaliser des travaux par le propriétaire (card F31699, version of 28 May 2025) - Service-Public.gouv.fr (DILA). Checked
- Modèle de lettre: mise en demeure du propriétaire de faire des travaux (R1746) - Service-Public.gouv.fr (DILA). Checked
- Loi n° 89-462 du 6 juillet 1989, article 6 (the landlord's obligations) - Légifrance. Checked
- Décret n° 2002-120 du 30 janvier 2002, article 2 (logement décent: clos et couvert) - Légifrance. Checked
- Décret n° 87-712, annexe (liste des réparations locatives) - Légifrance. Checked
- Détériorations dans le logement: qui paie? (card F21105, version of 21 May 2025) - Service-Public.gouv.fr (DILA). Checked
- Assurance habitation du locataire (card F31300, version of 16 April 2025) - Service-Public.gouv.fr (DILA). Checked
- Dégât des eaux: que faire? (card F1352, version of 25 July 2025) - Service-Public.gouv.fr (DILA). Checked
- Lettre recommandée électronique (card F31463, version of 10 September 2025) - Service-Public.gouv.fr (DILA). Checked
- Médiation des litiges de la consommation - Justice.fr (Ministère de la Justice). Checked
- Conciliateur de justice (card F1736, version of 1 September 2025) - Service-Public.gouv.fr (DILA). Checked
- Point-justice: annuaire des lieux d'accueil - Ministère de la Justice. Checked
- Pour l'accès au droit, à la justice et à l'aide aux victimes, un numéro unique: le 3039 (5 décembre 2023) - Cour d'appel de Toulouse. Checked
- SignalConso: comment ça marche - DGCCRF. Checked
- Location de voiture auprès d'un professionnel - Institut national de la consommation. Checked
- Location de véhicule: assurance (card F23420, version of 18 September 2025) - Service-Public.gouv.fr (DILA). Checked